The Benchmark

Loyalty cohorts that convert: the metric separating top brands

Edible Brands rebuilt its app and loyalty program in April. The results expose a gap most commerce operators are sitting on.

MarketplaceBy The Beacon desk, Lighthouse Strategy

April 2026. Edible Brands pushed a redesigned mobile app and a rebuilt loyalty program live. By October, chief digital officer Erica Randerson was calling the results meaningful. That word choice matters. Not record-breaking. Not transformational. Meaningful. Which tells you exactly what the baseline looked like before the relaunch.

What the benchmark actually measures

Loyalty program performance splits into three cohorts. Average brands track enrollment counts. Top-decile brands track 90-day repeat purchase rate per enrolled member. The best operators track net revenue per loyalty cohort after discount cost. That last number is the one that kills programs that look healthy on a dashboard. You can have 2 million enrolled members and a program bleeding margin on every redemption cycle. Most brands do not know which cohort they are in until a relaunch forces the audit.

What separates average from top-decile

Three structural differences show up consistently across operators who have closed the gap. First: personalization at the SKU level, not the category level. Sending a repeat buyer of a specific product a generic category coupon is a signal that your data connection between purchase history and campaign logic is broken. Fix the connection before you spend another dollar on creative. Second: push notification timing mapped to individual purchase cadence, not broadcast schedules. If a customer buys every 23 days, your app should queue a reminder at day 19. Not Tuesday at 10 a.m. because that is when your team sends emails. Third: redemption friction. Every additional tap between a member and their reward is a percentage point of drop-off. Edible Brands redesigned the app UI specifically to address this. That is not a loyalty strategy decision. That is a conversion rate optimization decision applied to your owned channel.

The Newegg signal you should not ignore

Newegg integrated Google's Universal Commerce Protocol for checkout this week. This is not a Newegg story. This is a signal about where checkout velocity is heading across every category. Agentic commerce channels are moving from experiment to infrastructure. If your loyalty program is not integrated with the checkout layer your customers are increasingly using, the program becomes invisible at the moment of highest intent. Your points balance does not show up in an agent-assisted checkout flow if you have not built that connection. Newegg moved. The question is whether your brand has mapped its loyalty data to the checkout surfaces where your customers will transact in the next 18 months.

Three actions for your next 30 days

Pull your loyalty program's 90-day repeat purchase rate by enrolled cohort. Segment by acquisition channel, not just by membership tier. If your organic cohort and your paid cohort have repeat rates within 2 points of each other, your program is not working. The paid cohort should be lower. If it is higher, your organic acquisition is broken. That is your first diagnostic. Second: audit your app's redemption flow with a stopwatch. Count taps from login to reward applied at checkout. If the number is above four, you are losing repeat revenue to friction, not to competition. Third: identify whether your loyalty data is connected to any external checkout surface. If the answer is no, that is the highest-priority integration project on your commerce roadmap right now. Not a rebrand. Not a new tier structure. The connection.

Three questions to pressure-test your loyalty program

Does your team know the 90-day repeat purchase rate for members enrolled in the last 6 months, broken out by the channel that acquired them? When a loyalty member is mid-purchase on a third-party checkout surface, does your program have any visibility or offer delivery into that moment? If your app went down tomorrow for 72 hours, what percentage of your loyalty-driven revenue would you lose, and do you have a number for that or are you guessing? Get the number.

From the publisher

Reading is free. Acting on it is where we come in.

When a story is about your category, a Discovery call turns it into a plan.